Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Moderator: Alastair
- Gunness
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1826
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2004 7:04 pm
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
- Contact:
Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
When I was learning English in grade school, my teacher wasn't terribly skilled - so I can say without hesitation that I've learned an awful lot from playing adventure games.
Now my daughter's ten, and she's been learning English for about a year and a half. She's awfully fond of reading (not in English, though), so I thought I'd try and show a text adventure (she's been showing some interest already).
But which one would be a good starting point?
Personally I started off with some of the Channel 8 and Brian Howarth games. They had very basic parsers and limited vocabularies, but on the other hand, the descriptions were manageable for someone with a very limited grasp of English.
Much as I like games such as Wishbringer or a cute title such as A Bear's Night Out, being faced with.
"You are in a dark dungeon"
is so much much easier to grasp than
"Moonlight plays through the window, softly illuminating the bedroom, full of comfortable memories"
Sigh. Dictionary overload.
Then again, the tech side of old games led to too many instances of "Sorry, I don't understand".
What's my best bet if I'd like a game with brief descriptions but a good vocab and parser.
Now my daughter's ten, and she's been learning English for about a year and a half. She's awfully fond of reading (not in English, though), so I thought I'd try and show a text adventure (she's been showing some interest already).
But which one would be a good starting point?
Personally I started off with some of the Channel 8 and Brian Howarth games. They had very basic parsers and limited vocabularies, but on the other hand, the descriptions were manageable for someone with a very limited grasp of English.
Much as I like games such as Wishbringer or a cute title such as A Bear's Night Out, being faced with.
"You are in a dark dungeon"
is so much much easier to grasp than
"Moonlight plays through the window, softly illuminating the bedroom, full of comfortable memories"
Sigh. Dictionary overload.
Then again, the tech side of old games led to too many instances of "Sorry, I don't understand".
What's my best bet if I'd like a game with brief descriptions but a good vocab and parser.
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
What about a multiple choice game like Danger Mouse in Black forest Chateau. It's not needed to understand every word and it is easier to solve because one can choose a command rather than having to write it oneself. Even without understanding every word you get a general idea of what you are doing. It was one of the first adventures I bought and I quite liked playing that one.
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Another game which should not be very difficult to start with if you give her a lists of verbs could be Aztec Tomb. It's not very big and not very hard to solve.
- Gunness
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1826
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2004 7:04 pm
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Thanks for the input I had thought about a multiple choice game but didn't know which one to get.
Something along the lines of Aztec Tomb would be nice. I honestly can't remember much of it.
To avoid scaring her away from the get-go, it's quite important that there aren't sudden death situations all the time, and that you can backtrack at any moment - for a beginner there's nothing worse than being stuck because you missed something that has now disappeared.
Something along the lines of Aztec Tomb would be nice. I honestly can't remember much of it.
To avoid scaring her away from the get-go, it's quite important that there aren't sudden death situations all the time, and that you can backtrack at any moment - for a beginner there's nothing worse than being stuck because you missed something that has now disappeared.
- Gunness
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1826
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2004 7:04 pm
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Any other suggestions, We've been playing a bit of Danger Mouse, which went pretty okay.
I know there are a number of multiple choice games, but most of the ones I can think of are fairly dull (Mickey's Space Adventure, Gelfling Adventure etc) or too difficult (the Adrian Mole titles)
Other parser based games would be okay, too - just to have a few things to choose from
I know there are a number of multiple choice games, but most of the ones I can think of are fairly dull (Mickey's Space Adventure, Gelfling Adventure etc) or too difficult (the Adrian Mole titles)
Other parser based games would be okay, too - just to have a few things to choose from
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Jacob, does it matter which dialect of English you wish to teach your daughter?
- Gunness
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1826
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2004 7:04 pm
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
If you're thinking about US vs British English, then no.
If it's a more challenging dialect, then... perhaps. What did you have in mind?
If it's a more challenging dialect, then... perhaps. What did you have in mind?
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Proper English versus that Webster abominationGunness wrote:If you're thinking about US vs British English, then no.
If it's a more challenging dialect, then... perhaps. What did you have in mind?
One thing I will add is that the BBC was the most popular micro in British schools, so there is a lot of education material available for the Beeb.
- Gunness
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1826
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2004 7:04 pm
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Ok, so if the Yanks are out ....
Might you, Sire, recommend any games that would suit my request? Beeb or otherwise?
Cordially yours,
Lord Gunness
Might you, Sire, recommend any games that would suit my request? Beeb or otherwise?
Cordially yours,
Lord Gunness
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
If thou art a Lord and thou addresseth me as Sire, what doest that make me?Gunness wrote:Might you, Sire, recommend any games that would suit my request? Beeb or otherwise?
Cordially yours,
Lord Gunness
(Returning to the 21st Century.) I wish I could answer your question, but my school never used computers in English lessons so I have nothing to suggest.
- Richard Bos
- Posts: 44
- Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 9:43 am
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Also... Danger Mouse! How could a game about David Jason's best role not be enjoyable?Alex wrote:What about a multiple choice game like Danger Mouse in Black forest Chateau. It's not needed to understand every word and it is easier to solve because one can choose a command rather than having to write it oneself. Even without understanding every word you get a general idea of what you are doing. It was one of the first adventures I bought and I quite liked playing that one.
Richard Bos
The Netherlands
Spectrum nut and T/SAL "expert". And very amateur chess player.
The Netherlands
Spectrum nut and T/SAL "expert". And very amateur chess player.
- Richard Bos
- Posts: 44
- Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 9:43 am
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
You're Danish, right? I don't know how appropriate the language is for your daughter (I find such matters hard to judge), but this one was aimed partly at English children and she should at least recognise the story: http://solutionarchive.com/game/id%2C13 ... C+The.htmlGunness wrote:What's my best bet if I'd like a game with brief descriptions but a good vocab and parser.
IIRC Zenobi published a few more adventures aimed somewhat at children. Have a look at Karen Tyers' games, some of hers might work.
And of course there's Giant Killer, which is still available for download for Windows from http://www.r-e-m.co.uk/topologika/index ... iller.html
Richard Bos
The Netherlands
Spectrum nut and T/SAL "expert". And very amateur chess player.
The Netherlands
Spectrum nut and T/SAL "expert". And very amateur chess player.
- Gunness
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1826
- Joined: Tue Dec 07, 2004 7:04 pm
- Location: Copenhagen, Denmark
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Yes, I'm Danish and yes, she knows The Snow Queen, so it might be an option. I'll give it a go.
Oh, Giant Killer looks like an excellent suggestion - never tried it, so would make for an ideal teamwork project. Thanks!
Oh, Giant Killer looks like an excellent suggestion - never tried it, so would make for an ideal teamwork project. Thanks!
- Richard Bos
- Posts: 44
- Joined: Tue Apr 20, 2010 9:43 am
- Location: The Netherlands
- Contact:
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Note that it comes with manuals for both student and teacher, the latter containing some pretty clear hints on the way forwards and how to solve the problems. I don't recall whether the standard installation immediately provides both, but they are both available.Gunness wrote:Oh, Giant Killer looks like an excellent suggestion - never tried it, so would make for an ideal teamwork project. Thanks!
Richard Bos
The Netherlands
Spectrum nut and T/SAL "expert". And very amateur chess player.
The Netherlands
Spectrum nut and T/SAL "expert". And very amateur chess player.
Re: Best beginner's game in English for non-native speakers
Note that although the set-up download for Giant Killer is a Windows executable, the game itself is a DOS program.